Week 7 Discussion

Re: Week 7 Discussion

by Shawn Pogue -
Number of replies: 0
Prompt 1
The 1920s in the United States is best characterized as a decade of significant cultural transformation. In the case of economics the era is recognized as a time of prosperity. This is shown by the dominance of the American dollar replacing the British pound as the cornerstone currency in global trade. This economic boom was largely supported by the expansion of consumer credit and mass production techniques, enabling the emergence of a nationwide consumer culture symbolized by the "Coca Cola Society". However, this prosperity was unevenly distributed, and the agricultural sector notably suffered due to mechanization and reliance on migrant labor, highlighting economic inequalities of the era. Culturally, the 1920s marked an important shift away from traditional Victorian morality towards greater personal freedom and social experimentation. This was most notably reflected in the Jazz Age, which fostered significant intermixing of races and cultures. Jazz music, predominantly created by African American musicians, gained mainstream popularity, blurring previously rigid racial boundaries. Despite these advancements, the era also saw the rise of intense nativism and racism, exemplified by the Immigration Act of 1924, which severely restricted immigration from Southern and Eastern Europe and entirely excluded Asian immigrants (Arnell 17). These contradictory developments economic prosperity alongside deep seated racism and cultural flourishing juxtaposed with restrictive immigration policies form the defining characteristics of the 1920s.

Prompt 2

The end of Prohibition directly contributed to Billie Holiday becoming a target of the federal government through the rise of Harry Anslinger and the newly established War on Drugs. After the repeal of Prohibition, Anslinger, who had previously been involved in alcohol enforcement, sought a new justification for his department's existence, choosing to aggressively target narcotics (NPR). Anslinger’s actions were deeply rooted in racism and personal animosity toward individuals struggling with addiction, particularly African Americans. Billie Holiday, who had experienced profound trauma and struggled with substance abuse, became a convenient and symbolic target for Anslinger due to her powerful anti-racist protest song, "Strange Fruit." Her song graphically condemned the violence and brutality of white supremacy (NPR). Recognizing the threat her performance posed to racial hierarchies, Anslinger aggressively targeted Holiday, going so far as to warn her to stop performing the song. Her refusal led to systematic harassment, surveillance, and repeated arrests, ultimately weakening her career and contributing significantly to her tragic decline and death.

Prompt 3

The Supreme Court's 1927 decision in Buck v. Bell was deeply connected to the eugenics movement and rising nativist sentiments of the era. Carrie Buck was institutionalized and forcibly sterilized after being labeled "feebleminded," despite her circumstances resulting from a sexual assault rather than any legitimate intellectual disability (Fresh Air). The infamous line from Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr., "three generations of imbeciles are enough," reflected the harsh and unfounded eugenicist beliefs that underpinned the decision. This ruling legitimized state-sanctioned sterilization practices, resulting in approximately 70,000 forced sterilizations nationwide (Fresh Air). Eugenics also significantly influenced immigration policies, such as the Immigration Act of 1924, aimed at preserving a supposed American racial purity by restricting entry from Eastern and Southern Europe and barring Asians entirely (Fresh Air). The Buck v. Bell decision remains legally intact today, underscoring the persistent threat posed by lingering pseudoscientific and racist ideologies, with potentially dangerous implications for future policy abuses.